Poll on appointment of Chapter / Working group Chair position

1 min read Nov 02, 2015

Dear Members of MCAA

What do you think about the matter that the Chair position of the Chapter / Working group should be rotational yearly or need to be remain same. Please vote 'Yes' to be changed yearly and 'No' to remain same.

Thanks

Best Regards

Shikhar

21 Comments

Profile Default Image
Angela Bellia

Regarding the Chair position of the Chapter / Working group, it should be rotational yearly, I vote YES

Profile Default Image
Marco Masia

It depends on many factors and it is hard to generalize. Some situations may require the chair to stay longer and some other to have a frequent rotation. Members of each chapter/WG should take this decision democratically. Having elections every year sounds a reasonable solution. Elections can be made quickly using online tools.

Profile Default Image
Daniel Praeg

yes rotational, not necessarily yearly - every 2-3 years?

Profile Default Image
Frauke Kersten

Until a chair has established all the connections and networks for successful managing and knows how everything works it will need some time. Also sometimes it might be difficult to find a candidate for taking over. For less active/some Chapters/Working Groups a rotational system of 1 year could work, but I would vote for a 2-year timespan. And for the possibility of reelection of the former chair for one more period.

Profile Default Image

I agree with Frauke Kersten and vote no, since more time to establish oneself in the position would be beneficial.

Profile Default Image

Yes, rotational. One-year or two-year format could be an internal decision of each chapter and working group.

Profile Default Image
Reyes Benlloch Ortiz

I think one year period is too little. Organizing Chapter or Working group is quite a work and take times for things to start going, so for me ideal should be two year rotaion time. Best regards,

 

Profile Default Image
Reyes Benlloch Ortiz

I think one year period is too little. Organizing Chapter or Working group is quite a work and take times for things to start going, so for me ideal should be two year rotaion time. Best regards,

 

Profile Default Image
Chengjun Yu

I graduated from Erasmus Mundus program, the preriod for election is one year, however, if after one year, the leader want one more year, she or he need to submit one report to state his contribution.

Profile Default Image
Chengjun Yu

I graduated from Erasmus Mundus program, the preriod for election is one year, however, if after one year, the leader want one more year, she or he need to submit one report to state his contribution.

Profile Default Image
Alessandra Conversi

it shouold be rotated buyt NOT every year, give the people the time to do something. Every 2-3 years

Profile Default Image
Chengjun Yu

It is just an election, no campain. one year is enough to do something, if well planned, which should be the requirement for candidate. Why not have selection/year? And election will remind people to join the group.

Profile Default Image
Claudia Simao

Hi Shikhar,

The chairperson of the WGs is already voted yearly. I don't understand your question.