and the 2020 Turing Prize goes to ... PIXAR

by michael rogers

Pixar pioneers behind Toy Story animation win "Nobel Prize" of computing

By Zoe ThomasTechnology reporter

  • 5 April 2020


Toy Story 4 posterImage copyrightGETTY IMAGES
Image captionToy Story was the first feature length film released by Pixar and has gone on to become a billion dollar franchise

In the opening scene of Toy Story, released in 1995, a cluster of boxes is scattered across a child's bedroom. The sun streams into the room as a Mr Potato Head doll demands money from a seemingly stricken cast of plastic and plush toys outside a cardboard bank.

Into the picture arrives the hero - a cowboy sheriff made of plastic and fabric with a pull-string to make him speak. The sheriff casts a shadow over the villainous potato who flees from the law.

It's a scene plucked from a child's imagination. It was also the culmination of decades of development in computer animation.

This year two of the men behind those advancements, Ed Catmull and Pat Hanrahan, are the recipients of the Turing Award. The award recognizes "lasting and major" contributions to the field of computing and is considered to be the "Nobel Prize" of computer science.

The award is given by the Association for Computing Machinery and comes with a $1m (£800,000) cash prize split between the winners.

Computer animation

Dr Catmull, one of the founders of Pixar, the studio behind Toy Story, and Dr Hanrahan, one of Pixar's early employees, were notified of their win in early March.

It gave the two old friends and former colleagues just enough time to meet for a celebratory meal before coronavirus lockdown measures were put in place in California, where they both live.

Pixar StudiosImage copyrightGETTY IMAGES
Image captionPixar Studio was "a magic place" to work according to Pat Hanrahan who helped the studio develop the software that makes 3D images

"The digital revolution we have seen in all kinds of movies, television, games - probably no one made more of the difference to that then Ed and Pat," says David Price, author of the book The Pixar Touch.

To make Toy Story and other computer-animated films possible, Dr Catmull, Dr Hanrahan and their teams had to develop ways to get computers to visualize three-dimensional objects.

During his postdoctoral studies, Dr Catmull created a way to make a computer to recognize a curved surface. Once developers had a mathematically defined curve surface they could begin to add more features to it - like texture and depth.

"Step by step you figure out what kind of lighting should be applied. Then you begin to put in the physics of it because plastic reflects light one way and metal reflects it in a very different way," Dr Catmull explains.

Dr Catmull had always had an interest in animation and film.

After earning, his doctorate and working in a graphics lab in New York, he eventually became the head of computer division of Lucasfilms, founded by George Lucas. The creator of Star Wars and Jurassic Park saw the potential of computer animation in movies.

But Dr Catmull's says his dream to make a feature-length computer-animated film was still seen as "wildly impractical".

"Most people dismissed the idea as an irrelevant pipe dream."

Pixar is born

In 1986 the Apple founder Steve Jobs came along. He bought Lucasfilms' computer division and turned it into a standalone company, Pixar.

At first, the firm tried to sell computer hardware. When that failed to take off, Pixar refocused on computer imagery.

Pat Hanrahan (left) and Ed CatmullImage copyrightED CATMULL
Image captionPat Hanrahan (left) left Pixar in 1989 but contributions helped Ed Catmull and the remaining Pixar team develop their feature films

Dr Hanrahan was one of the company's earliest employees. He was put in charge of creating a minimum standard for the way computer code is used to describe images.

"Pixar was a magic place," says Dr Hanrahan who now teaches at Stanford University.

He oversaw the creation of RenderMan - the software Pixar uses to create its 3D animation - working with teams from across the industry.

Shading and light

Crucially Dr Hanrahan worked out how to visualise how light reflects off of different surface. On surfaces like human skin some of the light passes through or is absorbed.

Getting this level of light and shade right gave the images a more realistic look.

RenderMan has been used to create animated films like Toy Story and Pixar's A Bug's Life. It was also essential for visual effects of live-action films including Terminator 2, Titanic and Jurassic Park.

Developments in computer animation drove the video gaming industry as well as advancements in virtual and augmented reality. And its progress has been tied closely to advancements in machine learning.

Ed CatmullImage copyrightGETTY IMAGES
Image captionDisney purchased Pixar in 2006 and Ed Catmull became the president of Pixar and Disney animation

"Waiting for computers to catch up

According to Dr Catmull, sharing work across the industry and with other sectors allowed for the bigger breakthroughs, particularly processing power.

Computers of the 1980s and 1990s had only a fraction of the processing power laptops and smartphones have today.

"[A lack of processing power] definitely was a limiting factor," Dr Catmull explains.

"You had to almost bide your time working on the algorithms for the compute power to catch up with the ideas that we had."

But even today computer-animated films rely on small armies of animators.

"It's a very labour-intensive process, we still have to do a lot of things manually," says Dr Hanrahan.

"If you just want to have a character walk around a world and have a human-like motion that makes you think it's natural, that's a huge problem…we have no idea how to do that well."

Developments in robotics have helped to make improvements in this area, demonstrating how crucial it still is to share learning across fields.

Steve JobsImage copyrightGETTY IMAGES
Image caption : Steve Jobs was mostly hands-off but offered an honest outside voice to Pixar's developers

Though Steve Jobs, was known as a very secretive leader at Apple, Dr Catmull says at Pixar he was far more open and understood the need to share innovations.

"Publishing was one of the things that helped us attract the best people. Getting the best people was far more important than any single idea and Steve understood that," says Dr Catmull.

Creations that last

Mr Jobs was also an essential outside voice for Pixar's films. He didn't work on them, but would drop in to give his opinion. One of the memorable things he told the Pixar team was that while computers would be thrown away every few years, the films they were creating would last for generations.

This is only the second time the award has been given for advancement in computer graphics.

The official ceremony to present the Turing Award is scheduled for June 2020.

The outbreak of coronavirus may have meant few people noticed when the announcement of Dr Catmull and Dr Hanrahan's achievement was made.

But with millions of people across the globe locked down in their homes, it is certain many have been watching the films these men made possible.

Survey button